Subscribing is the best way to get our best stories immediately.
The duration of a Cannes Film Festival standing ovation is often reported as a spot test on how good a film is, but film critics and journalists question whether the measure holds any merit.
Entertainment outlet Deadline reported that this year’s Spanish competition entry, “The Black Ball,” received a 20-minute ovation on Thursday night, just two minutes shy of Guillermo del Toro’s 22-minute record with “Pan’s Labyrinth” two decades ago.
Whether that long ovation predicted success at Cannes will be revealed on Saturday evening, when the jury hands out the Palme d’Or top prize to one of 22 films in the competition.
“It’s got all the ingredients for a long ovation,” Deadline awards editor Damon Wise said about “The Black Ball,” a 135-minute saga about the Spanish Civil War and gay representation in history.
“As the applause is drowning, going down, going down, going down, you cut to Penelope Cruz, and the applause comes back,” said Wise.
He added that last year’s second-place Cannes winner “Sentimental Value,” which went on to win best international feature at the Oscars, had a similar kind of ovation.
“I do think they (the ovations) do have their use,” he said.
“Pan’s Labyrinth” failed to win anything at Cannes but won three Oscars, for cinematography, art direction and makeup.
However, a lot of them are “performative,” he said, citing how Danish film-maker Nicolas Winding Refn actively encouraged the audience to keep going at his dark fable “Her Private Hell.”
Adding to the doubt is that standing ovation times vary from publication to publication, with Variety reporting that “The Black Ball” ovation was only 16 minutes.
“I’m not sure it really is a measure of a great film,” said Anna Smith, film critic and host of the “Girls on Film” podcast.
Smith said that the standing ovations start as a way of being polite, but then can quickly go out of control.
“Often I’ve enthusiastically joined in. But there is a moment where it does start to taper out a bit, and then someone will start up again. Then everyone sort of thinks, ‘Oh, OK, maybe I should join in’,” she said.
